boo :disappointed:
Should we ask the chairs to find an expert?
is there an expert we can suggest on the PC or ERC? https://icfp18.sigplan.org/track/icfp-2018-papers
The closest I see are Suresh Jagannathan and Marco Gaboardi—neither perfect…
yeah they might be the people who reviewed it already
So should we ask for an expert?
I think so
I’m particularly annoyed by “this isn’t functional programming”
you should note in your mail that matthew (the PC chair) is conflicted with the paper, and so you should maybe contact someone else
Right, that’s another thing to perhaps ask the chairs to possibly tell the jury to disregard. (Rajan and I only skimmed the reviews)
Boo indeed.
Yes, we should ask for an expert. Shouldn’t it be embarrassing for a conference such as ICFP to not be able to find “expert” reviewers for papers which are in scope?
Also, I love the way reviewer A thinks our evaluation is bad, and reviewer B thinks it’s good. And so on.
:thumbsup: on the email to Matthew Flatt.
Oh well, the email we sent has “XXX” in it :stuck_out_tongue:
Oops. I don’t think it will make an important difference.