samth
2019-4-19 12:07:18

Wow, 2 more


samth
2019-4-19 13:04:40

my other papers have 0 outstanding reviews


ccshan
2019-4-19 13:05:37

I reviewed 14 papers, of which one review is outstanding total.


samth
2019-4-19 13:08:03

And I know of 3 others, with 0 outstanding


samth
2019-4-19 13:08:26

So I guess that means Francois asked for more reviews


carette
2019-4-19 13:44:07

Should we hope he went out of his way for find reviewers who will rate themselves X?


samth
2019-4-19 13:45:01

I think it’s possible that at least 1 was previously assigned and is just late


samth
2019-4-19 13:45:16

and therefore there’s nothing we can predict about their expertise


samth
2019-4-19 13:45:55

but probably at least 1 was requested as an additional expert


samth
2019-4-19 13:46:16

although not everyone with expertise will rate themselves X


samth
2019-4-19 13:46:33

particularly since our paper draws on multiple areas of expertise


carette
2019-4-19 13:47:10

Indeed.


carette
2019-4-19 14:01:14

Note: I won’t have access to Slack for the next 32 hours or so. If my attention is needed on something, please email.