ccshan
2019-5-4 11:06:35

> To: <mailto:francois.pottier@inria.fr\|francois.pottier@inria.fr> > > Thank you so much for your extensive and conscientious work, Francois. Even just from what I can see, I know that it is why I am in this community in the first place. > > Now, if we could have the decision on our submission #105 please… :wink:


carette
2019-5-4 11:45:24

I got the (positive, yay!) decision at 6:08 ?


carette
2019-5-4 12:54:45

So as far as I can tell, we have no ‘mandatory changes’ assigned to us. There are, of course, things we’ll want to change, but that certainly makes things easier!


samth
2019-5-4 15:25:41

You got a decision?


samth
2019-5-4 15:25:48

Can your forward it?


carette
2019-5-4 15:26:00

Yes and yes.


rjnw
2019-5-4 15:27:04

I just did


carette
2019-5-4 15:27:25

You were on the ‘to’ list of the email I got from HotCRP.


rjnw
2019-5-4 15:29:42

It was which I think sam doesn’t use


carette
2019-5-4 15:30:16

But that’s how he was registered with the system…


carette
2019-5-4 15:30:53

[Not denying the truth of your statement, just that that is a weird thing to use an email that is not in actual use]


ccshan
2019-5-4 15:31:16

Do y’all see any sign of acceptance on hotcrp? I only see “submitted”


carette
2019-5-4 15:31:50

Did you get the email @ccshan?


rjnw
2019-5-4 15:32:04

I got an email of conditional acceptance


carette
2019-5-4 15:32:58

Indeed, I see no changes in hotcrp itself.


samth
2019-5-4 15:38:54

I do use that email and got all the other emails about that paper


ccshan
2019-5-4 15:39:32

I found my notification in my spam folder just now. I’ll ask Francois about the hotcrp status.


ccshan
2019-5-4 19:29:47

> > still says “Submitted”, not “Accepted” > That’s because the decisions are currently hidden from the authors. Furthermore, I will reset all conditionally accepted papers to “Undecided” in preparation for the second round of reviewing.