ccshan
2019-5-9 00:10:34

Our champion suggested writing ∫dx ∫dy ∫dz … instead of ∫∫∫… dz dy dx. @samth @rjnw As people who are closer to interpreters than integrals, do you think this change would make the paper easier to read?


samth
2019-5-9 00:15:47

I don’t think it makes a difference to me


carette
2019-5-9 01:57:41

I personally think it would make the paper harder to read. I heavily dislike that particular notation (which is very popular in physics). If I were writing a physics paper, I might have to resign myself to that, but a PPL paper? I don’t think so!


carette
2019-5-9 01:58:49

I have been reading all the diffs - very nice improvements. If there had been something I did not like, I would have said something, but there hasn’t been a need.


ccshan
2019-5-9 01:59:27

Please get ready to test an artifact for reproducibility in a couple of days.


carette
2019-5-9 01:59:49

Ok.


carette
2019-5-9 02:00:07

Does platform matter? We did have issues about that in the past.


carette
2019-5-9 02:00:51

I think my Maple is broken on some of my machines, so I’ll work on fixing that ahead of time, so that I’m ready to test when the time comes.


carette
2019-5-9 02:01:40

Actually, I should ask: what version of Maple is on karst now? I should use the same!


rjnw
2019-5-9 02:02:10

I wrote some instructions in the README file for hakaru-benchmarks https://github.com/rjnw/hakaru-benchmarks/blob/master/README.md


rjnw
2019-5-9 02:02:58

If you have ubuntu you can already try it, otherwise I will upload a virtual box image soon, I am rerunning all the benchmarks with the latest changes Ken pushed


rjnw
2019-5-9 02:05:03

if make setup succeeds without any errors you should be good to run all the benchmarks


ccshan
2019-5-9 02:10:38

You already understand the paper, and I bet you would still understand the paper with the dx-first notation. My question is whether more people would understand the paper with the dx-first notation.


rjnw
2019-5-9 02:26:01

I personally prefer the original notation


carette
2019-5-9 03:13:36

I am surprised that you’re even considering switching from a (weird) but well-bracketed notation to notation that is the equivalent of () expr. In my own notes, I add a delimiter to my sums, to make them well-bracketed too!