mark.warren
2021-4-30 12:13:05

@soegaard2 Trust no one.


laurent.orseau
2021-4-30 12:19:11

Is wellformed well-formed?


sorawee
2021-4-30 12:32:17

I’ve only seen the Wikipedia variant.



soegaard2
2021-4-30 12:41:08

But … maybe it just means american and british spelling differ here?


sorawee
2021-4-30 12:46:32

Huh… I got this result:


sorawee
2021-4-30 12:47:27

The well-formed result might be bogus, but I don’t think “wellformed” wins


soegaard2
2021-4-30 12:48:02

I got:


sorawee
2021-4-30 12:48:43

Try quoting wellformed as well?


sorawee
2021-4-30 12:49:02

I got:


soegaard2
2021-4-30 12:49:50

Huh? I thought quoting single words weren’t needed.


sorawee
2021-4-30 12:50:38

Right. What I’m trying to say is that I don’t think we know the semantics of quote here lol


soegaard2
2021-4-30 12:51:05

I am still confused - but now on a higher level :slightly_smiling_face:


sorawee
2021-4-30 12:51:06

I would expect the quoted and unquoted variants to give the same result


sorawee
2021-4-30 12:51:12

But they don’t


soegaard2
2021-4-30 12:56:47

Reading up on Google Ngram, I think the quotes shouldn’t be used. https://books.google.com/ngrams/info


ben.knoble
2021-4-30 13:02:08

Personally I prefer the hyphen (“well-formed”)


soegaard2
2021-4-30 13:35:46

Seems like you are not alone :slightly_smiling_face:


thechairman
2021-4-30 13:36:58

the rule of thumb I go by is compound adjectives are hyphenated before a noun, separate after it


thechairman
2021-4-30 13:37:06

a well-formed expression / this expression is well formed


thechairman
2021-4-30 13:40:41

“wellformed” looks common enough in tech contexts that I’d say it’s acceptable jargon, not explicitly wrong


abmclin
2021-4-30 14:12:19

interesting! I actually haven’t come across wellformed until now, I’ve only seen well-formed or well formed. Got to love Ngram Viewer


suzanne.soy
2021-4-30 19:37:32

I thought people would use JavaScript and web workers (which, it seems, require no user action to be accepted and to run in the background, even with the tab closed…), didn’t think of CI runners! :disappointed:


suzanne.soy
2021-4-30 19:39:58

On the other hand, I’m eager for more reproducible builds. Ideally, we wouldn’t really need most CI jobs, just running the build locally in a clean environment should be easy and should give the same result as a CI build…


sschwarzer
2021-4-30 22:16:09

I also had only seen “well-formed” so far, as far as I remember.

Generally I try to keep things simple in the sense that I use existing simpler words instead of combinations of them. For example, I prefer “file name” over “filename” and “well-formed” over “wellformed.”


jcoo092
2021-4-30 23:27:51

If it’s Wikipedia vs the Oxford English Dictionary, I would take the OED’s opinion every time