ccshan
2019-6-12 02:50:11

“You can submit an author response until Tuesday, June 11, 2019 23:59 (AoE).”


samth
2019-6-12 02:53:05

yes, which is ~8 hours from now


samth
2019-6-12 02:53:16

sorry, 9


samth
2019-6-12 03:15:26

I’ve added to both the document and the hotcrp site a draft of the “high-level” response


samth
2019-6-12 03:15:42

@rjnw can you work on the detailed issues?


rjnw
2019-6-12 03:16:07

I am trying


rjnw
2019-6-12 04:31:08

@ccshan is it the case that implementing something similar to Sham would require building a language extension for haskell?


ccshan
2019-6-12 04:42:51

If in Racket you can make do with just functions and not macros (and I think you can), then in Haskell you probably would just make a library and not a language extension.


rjnw
2019-6-12 04:44:39

we do use macros for variable bindings and function definition


rjnw
2019-6-12 05:56:16

I don’t know what to say for some of the detailed comments for reviewer C


ccshan
2019-6-12 05:56:37

Using ordinary functions (lambda) to express variable bindings (and probably function definition) would be idiomatic Haskell.


rjnw
2019-6-12 06:05:50

I saved a draft with my responses