rjnw
2020-2-3 17:57:14

we got the reviews for pldi


samth
2020-2-3 17:57:58

Yes. BBCC


rjnw
2020-2-3 18:01:49

there are not many comments, I will write some response and push it to github.


samth
2020-2-3 18:21:28

the web assembley comment is so dumb


rjnw
2020-2-3 18:24:51

yeah I don’t really understand comments like well why don’t you use this


samth
2020-2-3 18:26:04

also it makes no sense


samth
2020-2-3 18:26:13

WASM is even lower level than LLVM


ccshan
2020-2-3 19:49:21

It seems that y’all are ready to draft a response that emphasizes how Sham goes above LLVM (and well above WebAssembly) in terms of • interoperating with Racket • allowing AST rewriting for domain-specific optimizations • abstracting over LLVM annoyances • …? As a reviewer, I’m usually ready to go to bat for a paper to argue that it is a feature for a new solution to an important problem to be simple (“trivial”), but I guess it’s better for our response to leave that implicit. …?